Skip to main navigation Skip to main content Skip to page footer

How can mixing quality and particle integrity be ensured simultaneously with brittle ceramic granulates?

Brittle ceramic granulates, for example spray-dried press granulates made of alumina, zirconia, silicon carbide, ferrites or other technical ceramics, frequently need to be subsequently mixed with binders, lubricants, pigments, additives or dopants. This involves a conflict of objectives: the additives need to be distributed homogeneously across the entire batch, while the granulate particles must retain, as far as possible, the size, shape, porosity and flowability important for the shaping process.

Particle integrity is essential for the subsequent pressing process. Spray-dried granulates are used because their largely near-spherical shape and defined particle-size distribution support flowability and the reproducible filling of press tools. Changes in the particle-size distribution, in particular an increase in the fine fraction through abrasion or breakage, can change bulk density, flow behaviour, mould filling and compaction behaviour. The granulate size and its distribution in turn influence the green density, density gradients and behaviour during sintering.

For such tasks, mixing systems with low mechanical stress are fundamentally advantageous. Container, tumble, V-shell or double-cone mixers can be suitable where the components have similar particle properties and sufficient time is available for a diffusion-dominated mixture. These systems work mainly through rolling, restratifying and repeated splitting of the product layers. They avoid fast-running tools within the product space, but offer only limited options for distributing very small dosing quantities or introducing sticky liquids.

Vertical cone-screw mixers can be an alternative where gentle, convective circulation is required. A wall-hugging screw lifts the product while it falls back under gravity. With a suitable rotational speed and tool geometry, the resulting stress can be kept low. Slow-running twin-shaft paddle mixers can also be suitable for larger batches if their mixing intensity is matched to the breaking strength of the granulate. In general: a mixing system must not be assessed on the basis of its design type alone. Rotational speed, fill level, tool geometry, mixing duration, feed conditions and discharge substantially influence the actual particle stress.

High-intensity systems with fast-running size-reduction tools, cutting rotors or pronounced shear and impact zones are usually not the first choice for already finished, brittle press granulates. They can be sensible where agglomerates need to be specifically broken up or liquids need to be incorporated. For the pure final mixing of brittle granulates, however, the risk of abrasion and particle breakage rises with high mixing intensity. Whether a ploughshare mixer or another intensive mixing system can nevertheless be used depends on the granulate strength, the required mixing time and the permissible change in the fine fraction.

The process parameters must be set so that the desired homogeneity is achieved with minimal mechanical stress. Low rotational speeds and controlled product movement limit impact and friction energy. With rotating vessel mixers, the Froude number can serve as guidance for the state of motion. Rolling or gently cascading operation is generally gentler than throwing or centrifugal operation. However, a universally applicable target Froude number cannot be given, because vessel geometry, fill level, granulate properties and internals strongly influence the motion behaviour.

The fill level must suit the particular mixer. A fill level that is too low can cause large drop heights and increased particle velocity. A fill level that is too high reduces the effective restratification and can lead to longer mixing times. Instead of a generally valid fill-level range, the working range envisaged by the manufacturer should therefore be used as a starting point and then optimised with the original granulate.

The mixing time must be limited to the actual homogeneity requirement. Once the required mixing quality has been reached, additional processing time frequently only leads to further abrasion. This so-called over-mixing is determined through trials: representative samples are taken at various points in time, and both the distribution of a marker component and the particle-size distribution are assessed. The coefficient of variation of a suitable tracer or active component can be used for mixing quality. A blanket limit, such as a coefficient of variation below 5 percent, however, is not appropriate for all ceramic recipes. The permissible value depends on dosing quantity, sampling, analytical method and the quality requirements of the end product.

Particle integrity is assessed before and after the mixing process on the basis of the particle-size distribution. With press granulates, sieve analysis or imaging methods are often particularly informative; laser diffraction can be used in addition, provided the measurement method does not already destroy the granulate particles during sample preparation. At a minimum, fine fraction, oversize, d10, d50, d90 and the distribution width should be recorded. In addition, bulk density, tapped density, Hausner ratio, flow time and, where applicable, the breaking strength of individual granulates can be assessed. An increase in the fine fraction, changes in the Hausner ratio or an altered flow time can indicate attrition or structural changes.

Alongside the mixer itself, the entire periphery influences granulate abrasion. Critical points are feed locations, screw conveyors, pneumatic conveying sections, rotary valves, transfer points, discharge elements and drop heights. The granulate should be introduced into the mixer as evenly as possible and with a low drop height, and discharged gently after mixing. Baffle plates can reduce fall energy but can also cause additional friction or caking. The design must therefore be chosen on a product-specific basis. Gently guided chutes, matched transfer chutes and short free-fall distances are frequently more favourable than uncontrolled product drops.

With very small addition quantities, a premix can be sensible. The additive substance is first mixed with a small partial quantity of the carrier material; this premix is then combined with the main batch. This can reduce the mixing time required for the sensitive overall batch. Whether the method is suitable depends on whether the carrier fraction has the same particle structure and whether the premix itself can be produced without relevant abrasion.

The recipe also influences the robustness of the granulates. Binder content, residual moisture, granulation conditions and the drying profile determine the strength and deformability of the particles. An increase in granulate strength can reduce abrasion, but must not impair the pressing and sintering behaviour. Spray-dried granulates are frequently formulated deliberately so that they flow and transport well on the one hand, while breaking or deforming in a controlled way during pressing on the other. The optimal strength must therefore be designed for the entire process path — processing, mixing, transport, mould filling and compaction.

How amixon® supports gentle mixing of brittle granulates

Gentle product movement as a design goal

With brittle ceramic granulates, coated particles, crystals, instant products or spray-dried powders, preserving the particle structure is the primary concern. amixon® vertical mixers of the VM and HM series can be operated at low circumferential speeds. The manufacturer states an adjustable range of approximately 0.8 to 3.5 m/s for these systems; in practice, vertical mixers are frequently operated at low rotational speeds.

The SinConvex® mixing tools generate three-dimensional product movement: the bulk material is lifted near the wall and then flows back under gravity in the central area. With rotational speed, mixing time, fill level and tool design adapted product-specifically, this mixing principle can enable even distribution with limited mechanical stress. A complete exclusion of abrasion, particle breakage or temperature rise cannot, however, be promised generally. Particularly with brittle ceramic granulates, the permissible fine fraction, particle-size distribution and temperature development must be determined through trials with the original product.

Setting the mixing intensity in a targeted way

The mixing intensity is not determined by the design type of the mixer alone. It results from the combination of tool geometry, rotational speed, fill level, mixing duration, feed conditions and, where applicable, additional internals. For the pure homogenisation of sensitive granulates, fast-running size-reduction or cutting rotors are generally not used. However, where soft agglomerates need to be broken up or liquids specifically distributed, separately driven cutting rotors can be engaged locally and for a limited time.

The rotational speed of the main mixing tool, the mixing time and any use of a rotor can be stored as recipe parameters in the control system. This allows reproducible batch programmes to be implemented once process development has been successfully completed. The required mixing time should be limited to the point at which the desired homogeneity is reached. An unnecessary extension of the mixing time can lead to additional abrasion even at low rotational speeds.

Processing large batches gently on the product

According to the manufacturer, vertical single-shaft and vertical twin-shaft mixers can be built in sizes up to approximately 50 m³. Scaling up to larger batches, however, requires a fresh assessment of particle stress, since fill height, pressure loading, mixing paths, feed energy and discharge behaviour can change. A scale-up should therefore not be secured on the basis of circumferential speed alone.

For large batches, amixon® offers the Gyraton® mixer type GM. According to the manufacturer, sizes of 10 to approximately 70 m³ are available; for applications in the food industry, amixon® also states mixing silos of up to 100 m³. The mixing system operates with comparatively low installed power and is designed for the gentle homogenisation of dry, moist and pasty bulk materials. The Gyraton® can therefore be of interest for large-volume, sensitive products, provided mixing quality, particle integrity and discharge are demonstrated for the specific recipe.

Specialist solutions and wear protection

For particularly sensitive materials, the SpherHelics® hollow-sphere mixer and the KoneSlid® mixer can also be considered. These systems are designed for gentle product movement and extensive discharge. The KoneSlid® was developed in particular for products originating from spray drying, fluid-bed granulation or belt drying, whose particle structure should be preserved as far as possible. The achievable mixing time, the residual discharge and the actual tendency to segregate, however, always depend on the product, fill level and plant configuration.

For ceramic powders and masses, amixon® offers wear-protected designs. Depending on the abrasiveness of the product, wear-resistant materials, hardfacing overlays, hard-metal or ceramic protective systems can be used. With high-purity technical ceramics, it must be checked whether the possible abrasion of the chosen protective materials is compatible with the purity requirements of the product. amixon® states wear-resistant mixing and mixing-dryer systems for powder metallurgy and fine ceramics for batches of approximately 5 to 40,000 kg.

Verification in the pilot plant

The suitability of the mixing technology should be demonstrated with the original granulate. Mixer type, tool design, fill level, rotational speed, mixing time, dosing strategy and discharge conditions are varied for this. Alongside mixing quality, particle-size distribution, fine fraction, bulk and tapped density, flow behaviour, temperature development and, where applicable, the effects on mould filling, green density and sintering result should be assessed.

amixon® states that it operates more than 30 test units of various sizes at the Paderborn headquarters; supplementary pilot plants are located in Japan, India, Thailand, China, South Korea and the USA. The documented results can serve as a basis for determining the suitable machine and the permissible operating window for the later production scale.