Which features support process data acquisition and OEE optimisation in mixing processes?
Process data acquisition and the optimisation of Overall Equipment Effectiveness, abbreviated OEE, rest on the interplay of suitable sensor technology, reliable data integration, clear loss definitions and consistent evaluation. OEE is made up of availability, performance and quality. In mixing processes these figures must always be viewed in the batch and product context, since besides the actual mixing time, charging, dosing, discharge, product change, cleaning, sampling and releases also influence the plant time actually available.
Automated process data acquisition requires measuring points that meaningfully represent the process state, the quality and the plant condition. These include speed, torque, motor current and power consumption of the mixer drive. This data can provide indications of product behaviour, fill level, friction, mixing progress or possible build-up. However, it is not a universal substitute for mixing quality or viscosity. Its informative value must be checked for each product, each recipe and each mixer type by comparison with suitable quality data.
Temperature, pressure, vacuum, level and moisture sensors help to reliably monitor critical process parameters. Which measuring point is required depends on the mixing task. With hygroscopic powders, moisture can be decisive; with exothermic processes or thermally sensitive products, temperature; and with closed, inerted or vacuum-assisted processes, pressure and vacuum. Measuring points should not simply exist technically but should serve a clear purpose: they must monitor a relevant process parameter, make a deviation detectable at an early stage, or support a demonstrable decision within the process.
Inline analytics, that is, measurement directly in the process stream or in the vessel, can improve process and quality assessment. Depending on the application, spectroscopic inline moisture measurement, conductivity measurements, particle measurements or viscosity measurements, for example, may be considered. These methods can provide faster feedback than purely manual laboratory sampling. Their use, however, presupposes that the measuring point, calibration, evaluation algorithm, maintenance and the handling of implausible values are suitably defined for the intended purpose. In regulated applications, qualification or validation of the method may be required for this.
Monitoring of dosing is likewise central. Gravimetric systems dose by mass, for example via load cells or differential dosing scales. Volumetric systems dose by volume, for example via screws, pumps or defined stroke volumes. For batch traceability, target and actual quantities, raw-material batches, time stamps, dosing sequence and any corrections should be recorded. This makes root-cause analysis easier when quality deviations, incorrect weigh-ins or process interruptions occur.
Vibration, temperature and current measurements on motors, bearings, gearboxes and seals can support condition-based maintenance. This approach is often referred to as condition monitoring. It serves to detect changes in operating condition at an early stage. Building on this, predictive maintenance can be developed. It uses historical data and known failure patterns to estimate the likely maintenance need. Not every measurement curve is automatically suited to a reliable failure prediction. Prerequisites are suitable measuring points, sufficient data quality, known wear mechanisms and a clear maintenance process that converts conspicuous data into concrete inspection or maintenance measures.
For OEE evaluation, process, event and quality data must be linked to one another unambiguously in time. Precise time stamps are needed for charging, dosing, mixing, emptying, cleaning, product change, downtime and restart. An event capture that automatically detects unplanned downtime, short interruptions and waiting times, and is supplemented with standardised causes by operators or maintenance, is particularly helpful. Downtime should be classified at least as planned or unplanned, and by technical, material-related, organisational and quality-related causes. Without a uniform classification, OEE evaluations may well generate figures, but they provide hardly any robust starting points for improvement.
The six major loss types known as the "Six Big Losses" originate from the field of Total Productive Maintenance, that is, comprehensive productive maintenance. They typically comprise breakdowns, set-up and adjustment times, short stoppages, reduced speed, start-up losses and quality losses. For batch processes, these loss types should be adapted to the actual sequence. For example, excessively long cleaning, waiting times for raw materials or quality releases, remixing and delayed emptying may be more meaningful as their own loss categories than an unchanged adoption of a model from series production.
A structured data architecture ensures that measured data does not remain isolated. Standardised communication and fieldbus standards enable a vendor-independent exchange of structured data between controllers, historian systems, control systems and higher-level applications, for example for event-driven data transfers or for connection to Industrial Internet of Things and cloud applications. Which interface is suitable depends on the real-time requirement, the existing automation architecture, the security requirements and the desired data model.
A historian is a specialised database for time-stamped process and event data. It makes it possible to store and evaluate measured values, states, alarms and time series over extended periods. For batch processes, the data should additionally be linked to a batch ID, that is, a unique batch identifier, product ID, recipe version, plant identifier and process phase. The standard ISA-88, also referred to as ISA S88 or IEC 61512, describes models and terminology for batch control. This includes recipes, plant modules, operations, phases and batch records. ISA-88 can therefore be a suitable basis for structuring recipe management, process steps and batch documentation uniformly.
Digital recipe management reduces the risk of manual entry errors and supports the controlled execution of released parameters. It can, for example, manage mixing time, speed, temperature profiles, dosing sequence, fill level, target quantities and release steps. In regulated environments, recipes should be versioned, protected against unauthorised changes, and managed via defined release processes. Changes must be traceable. Where electronic records or signatures fall under applicable regulatory requirements, the requirements for data integrity, audit trails and, where applicable, electronic signatures must additionally be taken into account.
A golden-batch comparison compares the profile of a current batch with a defined reference profile of a demonstrably successful batch. The term "golden batch" does not mean that a single batch necessarily represents the perfect reference. In practice, a statistically validated reference range derived from several suitable batches is often more robust. Deviations in torque, temperature, dosing time, mixing duration or other critical parameters can thereby become visible at an early stage. Whether and how intervention takes place must be established in a clear process strategy, so that not every normal process variation triggers unnecessary alarms or operator interventions.
Various analysis methods are suitable for process optimisation. Statistical Process Control, abbreviated SPC, monitors the stability and spread of important process parameters across many batches. It helps to detect trends, drift and unusual patterns before defined limit values are exceeded. Design of Experiments, abbreviated DoE, systematically examines how several input variables jointly influence a result. This allows mixing time, speed, fill level, dosing sequence or temperature profile, for example, to be optimised in a targeted manner. Multivariate data analysis can additionally be helpful where many interconnected process and quality data are to be evaluated simultaneously.
A digital twin is a digital model of a real product, process or plant. It can take different forms: from a simple representation of recipes, capacities and throughput times, to a physically founded model of mixing kinetics, heat transfer, energy input or material properties. Digital twins can help with simulating operating strategies, capacity planning and assessing possible process changes. However, they do not replace trials with the actual product, particularly where particle flows, product build-up, mixing quality or emptying behaviour can only be modelled to a limited extent.
Cleaning has a considerable influence on availability in many mixing processes. Cleaning in place, abbreviated CIP, refers to the cleaning of plant components in their installed state without extensive dismantling. Sterilization in place, abbreviated SIP, refers to the sterilisation of plant components in their installed state, frequently using steam or another suitable method. Sensors for conductivity, flow, temperature, pressure and time can help to monitor cleaning and sterilisation cycles. Needs-based cleaning can reduce resources and downtime, but must not come at the expense of the required hygiene or the validated cleaning effect. In regulated applications, cleaning criteria, acceptance limits and the handling of deviations must be clearly defined.
For operation and evaluation, data should be visualised appropriately for the target audience. Role-based dashboards can show operators current process states and alarms, provide shift supervisors with loss-time and OEE trends, and enable quality or process engineers to carry out detailed process and batch analyses. Effective alarm management prevents operators from being overloaded by a multitude of simultaneous, unprioritised messages. EEMUA 191 is a guideline of the Engineering Equipment and Materials Users' Association, abbreviated EEMUA, for the design, management and assessment of alarms in process plants. It is frequently used as a point of reference for prioritising alarms and reducing alarm floods.
Mobile access can improve the availability of information, but requires a clear authorisation, security and release concept. Particularly for write access or remote access to controllers, access should be time-limited, encrypted, logged and designed according to the principle of least privilege. Standardised reports and regular shop-floor meetings, that is, short operational discussions held directly at the production area, help to convert OEE, quality and downtime data into concrete improvement measures.
How amixon® can support the OEE of powder mixing plants
Overall Equipment Effectiveness, abbreviated OEE, assesses the availability, performance and quality of a production plant. With powder mixing plants, these three factors do not depend on mixing time alone. Charging, dosing, discharge, product change, cleaning, maintenance, material flow, recipe management and the quality of the raw materials used are equally relevant. amixon® can support operators in improving these influencing factors and in assessing OEE potential on a sound basis, through product-appropriate machine design, project-specific automation, pilot-plant trials and service offerings.
The availability of a mixing plant can be supported by maintenance-friendly design features. With many amixon® mixers, the mixing tool is supported above the mixing chamber. This eliminates a lower shaft passage with an additional product-contact seal. A comparatively low speed and a reduced number of wear-relevant components can reduce maintenance effort. However, the actual service life depends on product, mode of operation, cleaning method, loading and maintenance strategy. Regular inspections and preventive maintenance help to carry out maintenance work in a plannable way and to reduce unplanned downtime.
According to the company, amixon® also offers support with condition-based or predictive maintenance on request. This requires suitable operating and condition data, for example run times, switching cycles, torque profiles, motor current, temperature or vibration. Possible changes in plant condition can be identified from this data. Alongside the measured data, an effective concept requires clear alarm and assessment limits as well as defined measures for when anomalies occur. According to the company, amixon® holds a large proportion of spare parts in Paderborn, offers lifelong spare-parts supply, and can provide selected wear parts to the operator as early as the initial delivery.
The complete batch time is decisive for the performance figure within OEE. Depending on the process, this covers not only mixing but also dosing, filling, discharging, product change and cleaning. amixon® mixing systems can help to shorten individual steps within this. The vertical mixer type HM generates superimposed mixing flows that can support intensive yet product-protecting blending. The KoneSlid® mixer type KS can, for certain applications, enable short mixing times and rapid discharge. However, figures for mixing quality after 20 to 30 revolutions are always product- and application-specific trial results. They must not be understood as a general assurance for all powders, fill levels and recipes.
Discharge also influences OEE, because it contributes to throughput time, product yield, cleaning effort and product change. Depending on product and machine design, the KoneSlid® mixer type KS can be emptied within a few seconds. ComDisc® technology supports moving residual product quantities towards the outlet. According to amixon®, depending on product and application, this can achieve high discharge rates of up to approximately 99.99 percent. As complete a discharge as possible can reduce product losses, simplify cleaning and reduce the risk of cross-contamination during product change. The residual discharge actually achievable should be verified with the specific product.
Product-change time is determined not only by the mechanics of the mixer but also by cleaning strategy, product sequence, hygiene concept, staff availability and release processes. A readily accessible, cleaning-friendly mixing chamber with reduced dead spaces can make manual cleaning, inspection and maintenance easier. Washing lances, as well as cleaning in place, abbreviated CIP, or wet in place, abbreviated WIP, can be provided on a project-specific basis. CIP refers to cleaning installed plant components without extensive dismantling. WIP describes wet cleaning within the installed plant, which, depending on the concept, can be carried out manually or semi-automatically. The actual cleaning time and cleaning effectiveness must be determined operator-specifically for the product, soiling, cleaning medium and method, and validated where necessary.
With the container mixer type COM, mixing, container transport, cleaning and filling can be decoupled from one another spatially or in time. This allows the central mixing station to continue to be used while other containers are being prepared or cleaned. However, cleaning time does not automatically block mixing capacity. The actual effect depends on the number of available containers, container logistics, cleaning stations, product change, quality releases and downstream process steps.
The quality component of OEE is influenced, among other things, by mixing quality, recipe accuracy, dosing precision, product yield and the number of remixes or reject batches. Suitable machine design can help to achieve a high and reproducible mixing quality within a defined operating range. However, mixing quality is not guaranteed across the board for a fill level of 10 to 100 percent. It must be verified for the specific recipe, taking into account particle sizes, density differences, moisture, dosing sequence, batch size and process parameters.
Recipes can be stored in a programmable logic controller, abbreviated PLC. A PLC is an industrial computer for controlling machines and processes. Recipe management can help to apply released mixing times, speeds, dosing sequences and other process parameters repeatably. Barcode-based material and batch identification, as well as connection to an enterprise resource planning system, abbreviated ERP system, can support traceability. An ERP system is corporate software for planning and managing resources, orders, materials and business processes. For deviations to be reliably detected and assessed, the data model, time stamps, user permissions, alarm management, data integrity and the handling of communication failures must be clearly regulated.
For the continuous mixer type AMK, amixon® describes a controlled start-up and shutdown mode of operation. The gravimetric feeders start together initially with a low mass flow and are coordinated with one another. The fill level rises; discharge is only opened once a defined operating state has been reached. At the end, the dosing streams are reduced in a controlled manner and the mixer is emptied. This procedure can reduce start-up and run-out losses. Whether this results in no products outside specification, referred to as off-spec, depends on the specific recipe, the stability of the dosing, the raw-material properties, the control system and the quality criteria.
Robust OEE assessments should not be based on general assumptions. Product-specific target and actual times for charging, dosing, mixing, emptying, cleaning and product change are needed. amixon® can investigate and document these process steps in the pilot plant with the original product. Such results can provide a well-founded basis for machine design, the definition of provisional target times and comparison with an existing plant. The transferability to the target size must be verified on the basis of product, fill level, geometry, mixing tool, material flow and process requirements. Pilot-plant trials reduce risks before the investment, but do not replace the performance acceptance test in later production operation.
In regulated production environments, amixon® can provide qualification-relevant documentation and support the operator with Design Qualification, abbreviated DQ, Installation Qualification, abbreviated IQ, and Operational Qualification, abbreviated OQ. DQ documents that the planned plant design meets the defined requirements. IQ confirms proper installation. OQ demonstrates that the plant functions correctly within the defined operating range. The starting point is the user requirement specification, abbreviated URS, that is, the operator's documented requirement specification.
The plant can be designed to project-specific requirements such as Good Manufacturing Practice, abbreviated GMP, ATEX, EHEDG, FDA requirements, 3-A Sanitary Standards or ASME. GMP stands for Good Manufacturing Practice and describes requirements for controlled manufacturing processes. ATEX refers to European regulations for equipment and protective systems in potentially explosive atmospheres. EHEDG stands for European Hygienic Engineering and Design Group and publishes guidelines for hygienic plant design. The Food and Drug Administration, abbreviated FDA, is the US authority for medicines, food and other regulated products. ASME stands for American Society of Mechanical Engineers and develops, among other things, technical standards for pressure vessels and plant components. Assessment of the regulatory requirements, process and cleaning validation, and validation of electronic systems including 21 CFR Part 11 remain with the operator.
According to the company, amixon® develops and manufactures at its Paderborn site. Centralised manufacturing and documented quality control can support the traceability of technical specifications, the provision of qualification-relevant documentation and long-term spare-parts supply. The long-term ability to reproduce individual components depends, besides the available technical documentation, also on the availability of suitable materials and bought-in parts, as well as the safety and regulatory requirements applicable at the time.
Summary
amixon® can support the OEE of powder mixing plants through maintenance-friendly design, suitable mixing and discharge systems, cleaning-oriented hygienic design, recipe management, batch traceability, and documented pilot-plant trials. Decisive are product-specifically determined times for mixing, discharging, cleaning and product changeover, together with clear recording of downtime, rework and quality losses. The actually achievable OEE always depends on the interplay of apparatus design, product and recipe, raw-material quality, production planning, cleaning, maintenance, operation and quality assurance.